29. April 2019
The British food store chain VM Morrison Supermarkets PLC (“Morrisons”) has been granted permission by the Supreme Court to appeal the data protection class action brought against it and to challenge the judgment for all its grounds. The case is important as it’s the first to be filed in the UK for a data breach and its outcome may affect the number of class actions for data breaches.
An employee who worked as a senior IT auditor for Morrsisons copied the payroll data of almost 100,000 employees onto a USB stick and published it on a file-sharing website. He then reported the violation anonymously to three newspapers. The employee himself was sentenced to eight years in prison for various crimes.
5,518 employees filed a class action lawsuit against Morrisons for the violation. It claimed both primary and representative liability for the company. The Supreme Court dismissed all primary liability claims under the Data Protection Act (“DPA”), as it concluded that the employee had acted independently of Morrisons in violation of the DPA.
However, the court found that Morrisons is vicariously liable for its employee’s actions, although the DPA does not explicitly foresee vicarious liability. The company appealed the decision.
The Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal and upheld the Supreme Court’s ruling that the Company is vicariously liable for its employee’s data breach, even though it was itself acquitted of any misconduct.
In the future appeal of the Supreme Court, it will have to examine, among other things, whether there is deputy liability under the DPA and whether the Court of Appeal’s conclusion that the employee disclosed the data during his employment was incorrect.
23. November 2018
Last week the U.K. and EU could conclude a draft withdrawal agreement for the United Kingdom to leave the European Union as of 30th March 2019. The agreement covers the “divorce” of both of them and a non-binding political statement concerning their ideas for the future relations. The declaration is referring to a commitment regarding an ambitious free trade agreement, containing areas including financial services, continued free flow of data, and other subjects relating to the EU such as defense matters have been picked up.
After the U.K. will have left the EU in March 2019 a 21-month transition period is planned in order to facilitating business sectors in their planning. Thus, at least until the beginning of 2021, EU regulations would remain effective keeping the U.K. in the single market and Customs Union. However, this time frame could also be extended by common agreement.
With regard to data protection, the withdrawal agreement directly addresses data protection and security issues in Articles 70 to 74. These provisions stipulate that EU data protection rules, including the GDPR, shall apply in the U.K. when using personal data of data subjects outside the United Kingdom exchanged before the end of the transition period. Furthermore, after the end of the transition period, the U.K. is obliged to further apply these EU rules to the processing of “EU personal data”, until the U.K. data protection laws to be enacted ensure an adequate level of data protection which is “essentially equivalent” to that of the EU. In the process of becoming subject to this formal adequacy decision to be established by the EU Commission the U.K.’s applicable data protection regime has to be assessed in the first place. In the event of annulling or repealing the adequacy decision, the provisions of the withdrawal agreement would be relevant for the EU personal data transferred to the U.K. to ensure the same “essentially equivalent” standard of data protection directly.
In other words, under the concluded agreement, the GDPR as well as the corresponding Data Protection Act would remain the applicable data protection law in the U.K. for the foreseeable future.